Review: Mockingjay (Suzanne Collins)

Mockingjay (The Hunger Games, #3)Where to start… I devoured this book as quickly as possible. I had to know what happened after the cliffhanger ending in Catching Fire. However, I was mildly disappointed. When the actual Hunger Games ended, there seemed to be something lacking from the plot. I had a hard time getting into the complicated political overthrow plot. This book also had some new characters that seemed a little out of place. Maybe out of place isn’t the right term. They were there, but I couldn’t figure out what purpose they served. It was hard to connect to any of them because there wasn’t much depth. It was as if they were there for the purpose of the plot’s subterfuge only. I really felt like there was no attempt to grow the new characters at all, except for maybe Boggs.

** Spoiler alert**

Then there is the problem with Katniss herself. In the other books I thought she was so strong and defiant. Now, she seems so weak. In the aftermath of the events in Catching Fire, it makes sense. Her mental breakdowns and nightmares are acceptable and one hundred percent justifiable. What annoys me, however, is her constant pity party. Everyone knows that bad crap happens (that was obvious in the first two books), but to keep harping on it drove me nuts. It’s as if we needed a constant reminder of how crappy life could be for her. Complete over kill.
I hate to say it, but this time around my favorite character was Finnick. He had the most depths out of all of the characters in this book. Oh, the secrets he has to share! Holy smokes. That was a dark turn I didn’t expect. But then he gets killed off. That irritated me. I really wanted him to survive. It’s not the fact that he died, either, that bothers me so much. It’s the manner in which he died. What a waste. That entire scene seemed so rushed and out of place. I didn’t even realize so many people died until two or three pages later. One of the major deaths in the book didn’t even stand out to me. I knew she died because of the massive bombing that occurred, but what was the purpose?
I will say that there was one surprise that caught me off guard. Peeta. Wow. I didn’t see that one coming. Poor, sweet Peeta.

No review would be complete if I didn’t talk about the ending. WTH?! I am so unhappy with how things ended. I’m all for Peeta, don’t get me wrong, but the way things were left with Gale seemed so wrong. No closure. I know there is supposed to be some great message about war and the roles we play—whether knowingly or not—but still… I felt so invested him that love triangle. I wanted a better solution. I don’t care so much who Katniss ended up with, it’s just the why that bothers me. It’s like she didn’t have a choice in the matter at all. She gets sent back to District 12 alone under the impression that no one will come for her. But then someone does… Only, it seems like he’s there because he has nowhere else to be. Did anyone else get that feeling? Obviously Peeta wouldn’t stay in the Capitol after what happened, so it only seemed natural that he would return to his home. With Katniss being there, of course they would end up together eventually. They are the only ones who can fully understand what it’s like to be a survivor of The Hunger Games. But does that mean he wants to be there with her or she with him? Not necessarily. It felt like they were both going with the hand life dealt them because they didn’t know what else to do.

** End spoiler alert **
I guess there was some sense of closure after the epilogue, but I still don’t know how satisfied I am with it. The pieces do fit together and there is plenty to think about afterwards, that’s for sure.  Leaving the series with this book unread would be wrong. Be forewarned, though, it’s a rollercoaster ride of emotions, and how you feel at the end really depends on whose side you’re on.


Amelia said... .

I agree wholeheartedly with this review. Characterization, I think, has never been one of Collins' strong suits, and in MOCKINGJAY, very few characters seemed to have any clear motivation. And what was UP with that ending?! Oi!

February 21, 2012 at 11:37 AM
Beth DeLong said... .

I totally agree! It seemed like the author was trying to find the quickest way to wrap things up to finish the series. The characters seemed very flat and wimpy. It didn't seem like Katniss made a clear "choice" ending up with P either. That was never explained. This book had more unresolved issues that the first two!

February 21, 2012 at 9:22 PM
A Backwards Story said... .

I applaud the way Suzanne Collins didn't back down from showcasing the way war destroys people, relationships, and life. She could have played it very safe or averted everything (Yes, BREAKING DAWN, I'm looking at you). But she went in full-throttle.

I think part of what everyone's complaint about MOCKINGJAY is stems from the abruptness. I recently heard that Suzanne wanted to do more, but Scholastic told her to keep it under 400 pages. Apparently, that's one of the reasons for two movies: So that Suzanne can tell the story the way she always wanted to. I'm interested to see what she left out and see if it changes opinions at all!

February 21, 2012 at 9:48 PM

Can't read the review! I haven't even read The Hunger Games. I know, I've got to get on it. I have it, it's just finding the time! I definitely will before the movie comes out. I'll come back and read your review after I read the series!


February 22, 2012 at 12:21 AM
The Flashlight Reader said... .

Amelia... OMG. The ending. What?! I know... still fuming on that one.

Beth... welcome to the dark side (i.e. book blogging). =) We need to catch up soon!

Bonnie... you are always so insightful. =) I love it. You are 100% correct. The abruptness is what killed me the most. I'm curious though, there will be two movies for Mockinjay? Interesting... I can't wait to see what she "adds." I'm glad she had a hand in writing the movie script. At least the movie version won't be a jacked up version of the book now.

and Heather... I am SO glad I'm not the only one that didn't jump on this bandwagon a few years ago. Hahaha. I read this series in a few days though. It's pretty engrossing.
February 22, 2012 at 12:55 PM

Post a Comment

Let the world know what you think... leave a message! I read them all!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Grab my Button

Flashlight Reader

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

2017 Reading Challenge

2017 Reading Challenge
Alanna (The Flashlight Reader) has read 5 books toward her goal of 100 books.

Rating System

Rating System

Blog Roll